DIY Expungement vs. Hiring a Lawyer in Indiana: What You Need to Know

Introduction: Is It Worth It to Handle Your Own Expungement?

If you're trying to move forward after a criminal case in Indiana, filing for expungement can be life-changing. It’s your shot at sealing your record, protecting your privacy, and opening doors to jobs, housing, and licensing.

But here’s the big question:
Should you file for expungement yourself—or hire a lawyer?

This blog breaks down the pros and cons of DIY expungement vs. hiring an expungement attorney in Indiana so you can make the best decision for your future.

Understanding the Indiana Expungement Process

Indiana’s Second Chance Law allows you to expunge:

• Arrests with no conviction (after 1 year)

• Misdemeanor convictions (after 5 years)

• Felony convictions (after 8–10 years)

But here’s the catch:
✅ You usually get one shot per lifetime to file.
✅ You must file in every county where you have a record—within 1 year.
✅ Errors can permanently disqualify you from expungement.

Option 1: DIY Expungement – Pros & Cons

Pros

1. Lower Upfront Cost
You won’t pay attorney fees, which can save $1,000–$3,000+ depending on your case.

2. Direct Control
You’ll handle the paperwork and communication with the courts yourself.

Cons

1. High Risk of Mistakes
Missing a case, filing in the wrong county, or using outdated forms can get your petition denied—and you may not get another chance.

2. Difficult for Multi-County Cases
If you have records in multiple counties, managing the 1-year deadline and different filing procedures is challenging.

3. No Legal Help for Denials or Prosecutor Objections
If the prosecutor objects or your petition is rejected, you’ll be on your own.

4. Time-Consuming and Stressful
It can take hours of research, court visits, and paperwork—especially if you're working or caring for family.

Option 2: Hiring an Expungement Lawyer – Pros & Cons

Pros

1. Accuracy and Efficiency
An attorney knows the law, forms, and local court procedures. They’ll ensure your petition is complete, accurate, and filed correctly the first time.

2. Handles Multi-County Expungements
They’ll coordinate filings in all counties, manage deadlines, and track progress across the board.

3. Help with Prosecutor Objections or Hearings
If your case is contested, a lawyer can argue your side, submit evidence, and speak to the court on your behalf.

4. Peace of Mind
Knowing your one shot is handled by a professional takes the pressure off you.

Cons

1. Higher Upfront Cost
Expungement attorneys in Indiana typically charge:

• $1,000–$2,000 for simple misdemeanors

• $1,500–$5,000+ for complex or multi-county cases

2. Must Find the Right Fit
Not every lawyer does expungements. Make sure you work with someone experienced in Indiana’s Second Chance Law.

When DIY Might Work—and When It Might Not

DIY Could Work If:

• You’re confident filling out legal documents and following court rules

Hire a Lawyer If:

• You have more than one case

• Cases are in multiple counties

• You have felony convictions

• You previously filed and were denied

• You need the expungement for employment or licensing

Real-Life Example

A client contacted Vining Legal after filing a DIY expungement and forgetting to include an old dismissed charge in a different county. Because of Indiana’s one-time rule, she couldn’t go back and fix it.

👉 Don’t let a paperwork error ruin your second chance.

Cost Comparison: DIY vs. Lawyer

Expense Type	DIY Expungement	Expungement Attorney
Filing Fees (per county)	$150–$200	$150–$200
Legal Fees	$0	$1,000–$5,000+
Time Spent	10–20+ hours	Minimal
Risk of Denial	High	Low
Confidence in Outcome	Uncertain	High

Conclusion: Choose Wisely—Your Future Depends on It

You only get one chance to expunge your Indiana criminal record. While DIY may save you money up front, the risks of mistakes, delays, and denials can cost far more in the long run.

If your record affects your career, housing, or reputation, hiring an expungement attorney is often worth the investment.

📞 Need help with expungement in Indiana? Call Vining Legal at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation today to protect your one chance at a clean slate.

Schedule a Consultation