Fight Back Against False Accusations: 5 Hacks to Win Your PO Hearing in Indiana

False accusations can turn your life upside down—especially when they lead to a protective order (PO) hearing. In Indiana, a PO can limit your freedom, remove you from your home, and damage your reputation—even before criminal charges are filed. If you’ve been falsely accused of domestic violence or harassment, your best move is to fight smart—and fast.

In this guide, I’ll share 5 key strategies (aka legal hacks) to give yourself the best shot at winning your Indiana protective order hearing. I’ve helped countless clients navigate this exact situation. Let’s walk through what works—and what mistakes to avoid.

1. Understand What You’re Up Against

In Indiana, protective orders are civil—not criminal—proceedings, but they carry serious consequences. The petitioner doesn’t need to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt. Instead, they just need to show that the alleged behavior “may” constitute domestic violence, stalking, harassment, or a credible threat under Indiana Code 34-26-5.

Here’s the twist: if the order is granted, it can still lead to criminal penalties if you violate it—even unintentionally.

🔗 Indiana Protective Order Defense: How to Fight Back

2. Hack #1: Document Your Side Immediately

Start building your case the second you learn a protective order has been filed. This means:

• Writing down everything that happened—dates, times, places, texts, witnesses.

• Taking screenshots of messages or social media posts that contradict the accusations.

• Collecting evidence that supports your character (e.g., awards, community involvement, family relationships).

⚠️ Do not reach out to the accuser. That can violate a no-contact order—even if you're trying to resolve things.

Related: 5 Mistakes to Avoid When Falsely Accused of Domestic Violence

3. Hack #2: Challenge Weak or No Evidence

The court will look for a pattern of behavior or specific recent events that justify a protective order. But here’s the thing: not all accusations are backed by solid proof. At the hearing, your lawyer can question:

• Whether the petitioner has physical evidence (texts, police reports, photos).

• Whether there are witnesses who can back up or dispute the claims.

• Whether the petitioner’s story is consistent—or full of holes.

🔗 What Evidence Do You Need for a Protective Order in Indiana?

4. Hack #3: Use Witnesses Wisely

Witnesses can make or break your hearing. This includes:

• Friends or family who were present during alleged incidents.

• People who’ve seen the petitioner’s behavior (especially if it undermines their credibility).

• Neutrals like neighbors or co-workers.

Bonus: character witnesses who can testify to your peaceful nature can sway the judge—especially if there’s no real evidence of violence or threats.

🔗 Defending Against False Domestic Violence Accusations in Indiana

5. Hack #4: Use Self-Defense as a Legal Strategy

If there was an altercation, and you were defending yourself or someone else, Indiana law protects your right to reasonable force. This is especially important if:

• You were reacting to someone else's aggression.

• You called the police yourself.

• You have injuries or medical records that support your account.

🔗 Self-Defense in Indiana Domestic Violence Cases

6. Hack #5: Get the Right Lawyer on Your Side

Don’t go into court alone. A skilled Indiana protective order defense attorney can:

• Challenge the evidence.

• Cross-examine the accuser and their witnesses.

• Present your side clearly and powerfully.

• Protect your rights if the accuser is also pursuing criminal charges.

An attorney can often get the case dismissed before the hearing or negotiate a better outcome—especially when the protective order is being used as leverage in a custody or divorce dispute.

🔗 How to Win a Protective Order Hearing

Conclusion: Take the Accusation Seriously—But Don’t Panic

A false accusation doesn’t have to ruin your future—but only if you act fast and smart. These five strategies are your first line of defense. I’m Nathan Vining, and at Vining Legal, I’ve helped clients across Indiana fight back against protective orders and related domestic violence charges.

Let’s fight this together.
📞 Call or text (317) 759-3225
📅 Schedule your free consultation

Schedule a Consultation