What Evidence Do You Need for a Protective Order in Indiana?
I. Introduction
A protective order, also known as a restraining order, is a legal tool designed to protect individuals from harassment, abuse, stalking, or threats. In Indiana, a protective order can provide immediate safety by legally prohibiting an abuser from contacting or approaching the victim.
However, obtaining a protective order isn't automatic—you must show the court that there's a real and present danger. That means providing specific evidence to support your request. This article breaks down the types of evidence that are helpful and how to present them effectively in court.
II. Types of Evidence
Indiana courts consider both direct and circumstantial evidence when deciding whether to grant a protective order.
Direct Evidence
Direct evidence directly proves a fact without inference. It’s typically the strongest type of evidence and includes:
Eyewitness testimony – Statements from someone who saw or heard the abusive behavior.
Video or audio recordings – Footage of threats, harassment, or violence, including surveillance or phone recordings (if legally obtained).
Physical evidence – Visible injuries such as bruises, cuts, or property damage.
Medical records – Documentation of treatment for injuries consistent with abuse.
Police reports – Official accounts of incidents that show a pattern of threatening or violent behavior.
Circumstantial Evidence
Circumstantial evidence suggests abuse through patterns of behavior or surrounding facts. Courts often rely on this when direct evidence is limited:
Threats – Repeated verbal, written, or digital threats.
Harassment – Unwanted contact, especially after being told to stop.
Stalking – Following, showing up uninvited, or tracking your location.
Previous incidents of abuse – A history of violence or controlling behavior, even if it wasn’t reported at the time.
III. Gathering Evidence
Being proactive and organized can make a major difference in your case. Here are key steps to take:
Document everything – Keep a written log or journal detailing incidents of abuse. Include dates, times, locations, what happened, and how you felt.
Take photos or videos – If you have visible injuries or property damage, photograph it as soon as possible.
Save communications – Don’t delete threatening texts, voicemails, emails, or social media messages. Screenshot or download them to preserve the record.
Get witness statements – If someone saw or heard the abuse, ask them to provide a written statement or be willing to testify.
Obtain medical records – If you were treated for injuries, request copies of your records to support your claims.
File a police report – Even if you’re not ready to press criminal charges, a police report documents the incident for future use.
IV. Presenting Evidence in Court
When it’s time to appear before a judge, preparation is key:
Be ready to testify – You may be asked to describe the abuse in your own words. Be specific and stick to the facts.
Bring all supporting documents – Organize your evidence ahead of time so you can present it clearly and efficiently.
Be honest and straightforward – Judges are looking for consistent, credible stories. Don’t exaggerate, but don’t minimize your experience either.
The court may also consider the respondent’s history and any criminal records or previous protective orders when making a decision.
V. Conclusion
If you're seeking a protective order in Indiana, gathering strong evidence is essential. Whether it's photos of injuries, threatening messages, or testimony from a trusted witness, each piece of evidence helps the court understand your need for protection.
If you're experiencing domestic violence, stalking, or harassment, don't go through this process alone. At Vining Legal, we help clients across Indiana navigate the legal system and obtain the protection they deserve.
Contact us today to schedule a consultation or call/text (317) 759-3225. You are not alone—and you do have legal options.
Schedule a Consultation
