How to Beat a Domestic Violence Charge in Indiana: Know Your Rights and Legal Defenses
Accused of domestic violence in Indiana? Don’t panic—an arrest is not a conviction. But what you do next could shape your future. I’m Nathan Vining, an Indiana criminal defense attorney, and I’ve helped clients statewide fight and win domestic violence cases. These cases are serious and often emotionally charged—but there are strong defenses available. This guide explains the law, your legal options, and how to take control of your case before it controls you.
What Counts as Domestic Violence in Indiana?
Under Indiana Code § 35-31.5-2-78, domestic violence includes offenses against a family or household member—spouses, exes, co-parents, people you live with, and others with a close relationship.
Common charges include:
Battery: Physical contact (from pushing to punching).
Assault or Intimidation: Threats of harm or coercion.
Stalking: Repeated unwanted contact or following.
Violation of a protective order.
Penalties vary from Class A misdemeanors (up to 1 year in jail and $5,000 fines) to felony charges carrying years in prison. A conviction can impact child custody, employment, housing, and even gun rights.
Top Legal Defenses in Indiana Domestic Violence Cases
Being charged doesn’t mean you’re guilty. Here are proven defenses that work in Indiana courtrooms:
1. Self-Defense
Indiana law under IC 35-41-3-2 allows you to use reasonable force to defend yourself. If your accuser struck first, your response may be protected. We’ll gather proof—witnesses, 911 calls, medical records, or surveillance—to back it up.
→ Dive deeper: Self-Defense in Indiana Domestic Violence Cases: Protecting Yourself While Protecting Your Rights
2. False Accusations
Custody disputes or breakups can fuel false claims. If the accusation was made out of revenge, to gain leverage, or based on a misunderstanding, we’ll dig into inconsistencies in their story and present digital or witness evidence that tells the real story.
→ Learn more: Defending Against False Domestic Violence Accusations in Indiana
3. Lack of Evidence
No visible injuries? No credible witnesses? “He said, she said” alone may not meet the burden of proof. We’ll challenge the state’s case and demand real evidence.
4. Defense of Others
Were you protecting a child or someone else? Indiana law allows force to defend others in danger. The facts matter—who was at risk and why?
5. Accidental Injury
Not every injury is intentional. A fall or accident can be misinterpreted as violence. Scene photos, context, and your testimony can help make that clear.
6. Constitutional Violations
Unlawful searches, coerced statements, or denied Miranda rights can result in key evidence being suppressed. We’ll review every step of your arrest for police errors.
Avoid This Critical Mistake Before Court
One misstep can sabotage your defense—especially talking to the police without a lawyer or violating a protective order.
→ Don’t make this mistake: Domestic Violence: The 1 Mistake You Can't Make Before Court
Building a Strong Defense: What Evidence Helps?
Start gathering this ASAP:
Photos or video: Injuries (yours or theirs), property damage, or the scene.
Witness statements: Neighbors, roommates, or bystanders who saw or heard what happened.
Medical records: Documenting your injuries or lack of theirs.
Texts, emails, or social media: Digital proof of relationships, tone, or motives.
Even small details can shift a case in your favor. Not sure what to collect? I’ll help guide you step-by-step.
Why You Need a Domestic Violence Defense Attorney in Indiana
You’re not just facing jail—you’re facing a lifelong record. At Vining Legal, we:
Know Indiana’s domestic violence laws and local judges.
File motions to suppress evidence or dismiss charges.
Negotiate favorable plea deals or fight in trial if needed.
Work fast to protect your rights, your job, and your family.
Whether you're in Indianapolis, Greenwood, or Fort Wayne—I’ll help you build the best defense possible.
What to Expect After You’re Charged
Here’s what the court process typically looks like:
Initial Hearing– You enter a plea, often “not guilty.” A no-contact order may be issued.
Pre-trial hearings – Evidence is exchanged. We may file motions to dismiss or suppress.
Negotiation or Trial – If a plea deal isn’t in your best interest, we go to trial.
Sentencing or Dismissal – If convicted, penalties are imposed. If dismissed, we’ll explore expungement options.
You must follow protective orders to the letter—even if you think they're unfair.
Minimizing the Fallout if Convicted
Even with a conviction, your life isn’t over. Here's how we limit the damage:
Character letters – From employers or community leaders.
Counseling – Shows rehabilitation and responsibility.
Parenting plans – If children are involved, we protect your role.
Batter’s intervention program - often required by Courts and starting on preemptively can help negotiations.
Conclusion: Don’t Let One Charge Define You
A domestic violence accusation is serious—but not unbeatable. You have legal rights, and with the right defense strategy, you can protect your record, your freedom, and your future.
📞 Call Vining Legal at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a confidential consultation today. We’ll review your case and build a strategy tailored to you.
Schedule a Consultation
