What Happens If You’re Charged With a Crime You Didn’t Commit in Indiana?

Introduction: Facing False Criminal Charges in Indiana

Being wrongfully accused of a crime is a terrifying experience. You may assume that if you're innocent, the truth will come out, and the charges will be dropped—but that’s not always the case. Many innocent people have faced wrongful convictions simply because they didn’t know how to protect themselves.

If you're falsely accused of a crime in Indiana, you must take action immediately to protect your rights. One wrong move—like speaking to police without an attorney—can jeopardize your case.

This guide explains:
✔ Steps to take immediately if falsely accused
✔ Why you should never speak to police without a lawyer
✔ How evidence and alibis can prove your innocence
✔ The dangers of social media and discussing your case
✔ How an experienced defense attorney can fight wrongful charges

📞 Falsely accused? Protect your future—call Vining Legal LLC at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation today.

Steps to Take Immediately If You’re Falsely Accused of a Crime

If you are accused of a crime you didn’t commit, follow these critical steps:

✅ 1. Stay Calm & Do Not Resist Arrest

🚨 Even if you are innocent, arguing or resisting can make the situation worse.

✔ Remain polite and cooperative.
✔ Avoid making any statements about the case.
✔ Do not try to “clear things up”—you may say something that’s used against you.

📌 TIP: Anything you say can and will be used against you in court—even if it seems harmless.

➡ Related Read: Learn what to do after an arrest in Indiana.

✅ 2. Do NOT Talk to Police Without an Attorney

🚨 NEVER assume that explaining your innocence will help. Police are trained to gather evidence against you—not to clear your name.

Instead, say:
🗣️ "I want to remain silent and speak with my attorney."

✔ Once you invoke this right, police must stop questioning you.
✔ A lawyer will ensure you don’t accidentally say something that hurts your case.

📌 TIP: Police can legally lie to you during interrogations to get you to confess. Don’t fall for their tactics!

✅ 3. Collect and Preserve Evidence

Your best defense is strong evidence that proves your innocence.

✔ Write down everything you remember about the incident.
✔ Identify witnesses who can confirm your whereabouts.
✔ Save text messages, emails, GPS records, or receipts that prove your alibi.
✔ Do NOT delete social media posts or texts—this could be seen as tampering with evidence.

📌 TIP: If someone is accusing you falsely, document their motives (such as revenge, child custody disputes, or mistaken identity).

How Evidence and Alibis Can Prove Your Innocence

Your defense attorney will use the following to prove your innocence:

Alibi Evidence

📍 Where were you at the time of the crime? If you were somewhere else, your lawyer can use:
✔ Surveillance footage
✔ GPS records (Uber, Google Timeline, etc.)
✔ Witness statements

Forensic & Physical Evidence

Evidence at the crime scene may clear you, such as:
✔ DNA or fingerprint analysis
✔ Surveillance footage showing the actual perpetrator
✔ Phone records proving you weren’t in the area

Witness Testimony

A witness may be able to testify that:
✔ They saw someone else commit the crime.
✔ You were with them at the time of the crime.

📌 TIP: An attorney can interview and subpoena witnesses to strengthen your defense.

The Dangers of Social Media: What NOT to Do

🚨 Social media can ruin your defense. Anything you post may be used against you—even if it’s unrelated to the case.

✔ Do NOT post about your arrest or charges.
✔ Do NOT message the accuser or try to “clear things up.”
✔ Do NOT delete posts or messages—this could be seen as destroying evidence.

📌 TIP: Set your accounts to private and avoid posting anything until your case is resolved.

How a Defense Attorney Can Help Fight Wrongful Charges

Even if you are innocent, you need a skilled defense attorney to:

✔ Challenge weak or false evidence
✔ Present alibi witnesses and forensic proof
✔ Cross-examine the accuser to expose lies or inconsistencies
✔ Negotiate with prosecutors to drop or dismiss charges

📌 TIP: Hiring a lawyer early can prevent wrongful convictions. Don’t wait until it’s too late!

📞 Charged with a crime you didn’t commit? Contact Vining Legal LLC at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation today.

Conclusion: Protect Yourself If You Are Wrongfully Accused

🚨 Being charged with a crime you didn’t commit is serious—but you have legal options.

✔ Remain silent and request an attorney immediately.
✔ Gather and preserve all evidence proving your innocence.
✔ Avoid social media and any contact with the accuser.
✔ Hire an experienced defense attorney to fight the charges.

📞 Need legal help? Contact Vining Legal LLC at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation today.

Schedule a Consultation