Building a Strong Custody Case: What Judges Look For in Indiana
Introduction: How to Strengthen Your Custody Case
Winning a custody case in Indiana requires more than just wanting to be with your child—you must prove to the court that you provide the best environment for their well-being. Judges evaluate several factors when determining custody arrangements, and understanding what courts look for in a strong custody case can help you prepare effectively.
If you're in a custody battle, working with an experienced Indiana child custody attorney can help ensure your case is well-documented, strategic, and focused on your child's best interests.
📞 Need legal help? Contact Vining Legal LLC at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation.
What Indiana Judges Consider in Custody Cases
Under Indiana Code § 31-17-2-8, courts determine custody based on the best interests of the child. Key factors judges evaluate include:
The child's age and developmental needs
Each parent’s ability to provide a stable home environment
The child’s relationship with each parent
Each parent’s willingness to co-parent
Any history of domestic violence or substance abuse
The child’s preference (if they are 14 or older)
A strong custody case focuses on proving stability, active parenting, and a child-centered approach.
How to Build a Strong Custody Case in Indiana
1. Be Actively Involved in Your Child’s Life
Judges want to see that you are consistently engaged in your child’s daily activities. Ways to show this include:
✔ Attending school events, parent-teacher meetings, and extracurricular activities
✔ Keeping medical and educational records to demonstrate involvement
✔ Maintaining a strong emotional bond by spending quality time together
➡ TIP: Read more about the power of active involvement.
2. Show That You Provide a Stable Home
A stable and nurturing home environment is a key factor in custody decisions. Courts look at:
✔ Your living situation—is your home safe, clean, and child-friendly?
✔ Your financial ability to provide for the child’s needs
✔ Your daily routine and ability to maintain structure for your child
If you recently moved or changed jobs, be prepared to explain how your new circumstances are in the child’s best interests.
➡ TIP: Read more about how stability can give you the edge in your custody case.
3. Encourage a Positive Co-Parenting Relationship
Judges prefer parents who foster a healthy relationship between the child and the other parent. Avoid:
❌ Speaking negatively about the other parent in front of the child
❌ Refusing to cooperate on joint decisions
❌ Blocking phone calls or visitation time
Instead, show that you respect co-parenting by communicating professionally and supporting shared decision-making.
➡ TIP: Learn about how to to develop a positive co-parenting relationship.
4. Keep Detailed Records & Evidence
Strong documentation helps support your claims in court. Collect:
📌 Texts, emails, and call logs showing co-parenting efforts
📌 Financial records proving child support payments or caregiving expenses
📌 Witness statements from teachers, caregivers, or family members
A well-documented case strengthens your credibility and proves your commitment to your child.
➡ TIP: Keep a parenting journal to document your involvement.
5. Avoid Common Mistakes That Can Hurt Your Case
Some parents unknowingly harm their custody case by:
❌ Missing scheduled visitations
❌ Violating the existing custody order
❌ Making false accusations against the other parent
❌ Posting negative or inappropriate content on social media
➡ TIP: Be mindful of your online presence—social media posts can be used as evidence against you in court.
What If the Other Parent is Trying to Undermine Your Case?
If the other parent is interfering with visitation, making false allegations, or attempting parental alienation, take action by:
✔ Documenting violations – Keep records of denied visits or harmful behavior.
✔ Filing a motion for contempt – If the other parent is violating court orders, legal action may be necessary.
✔ Requesting a custody modification – If the other parent is harming the child’s relationship with you, the court may adjust custody.
➡ Related Read: Learn what happens when one parent violates a custody order.
Why You Need an Experienced Child Custody Attorney
A custody battle can be complex, emotional, and legally challenging. An Indiana child custody attorney can:
✔ Help gather and present compelling evidence in court
✔ Negotiate parenting plans and modifications
✔ Protect your rights against false allegations or custody violations
📞 Need legal guidance? Contact Vining Legal LLC at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation.
Conclusion: Take the Right Steps to Build a Strong Custody Case
To win a custody case, judges must see that you provide a stable, loving, and supportive environment for your child. The key strategies include:
✔ Being actively involved in your child’s life
✔ Providing a stable home environment
✔ Encouraging a positive co-parenting relationship
✔ Keeping strong documentation and evidence
📞 Need help with your custody case? Contact Vining Legal LLC today at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation.
