Appealing a Divorce or Custody Ruling in Indiana: When Can You Challenge a Court Decision?
Have you recently received a final divorce decree or child custody order in Indiana and feel that the outcome simply isn't right? You're not alone. Many people walk away from court feeling disappointed, confused, or even outraged by the judge’s decision. Fortunately, Indiana law does offer a way to challenge certain decisions through an appeal—when specific legal or factual errors are present.
Despite what you might think, a judge’s decision isn’t always the final word. In some situations, you may have the right to appeal. But appealing a divorce or custody ruling in Indiana is not simply a second chance to argue your case—it’s a structured legal process that focuses on identifying mistakes that occurred at trial. This article explains when you can appeal, what types of errors may qualify, and when a post-divorce modification might be more appropriate.
What Does it Mean to Appeal a Family Law Decision in Indiana?
When you file an appeal in an Indiana divorce or custody case, you're asking a higher court—the Indiana Court of Appeals—to review the decision made by the trial court. But this isn’t a new trial. The appellate court doesn't accept new witnesses, new testimony, or new documents. Instead, it reviews what happened at trial to determine whether a legal or factual mistake was made that affected the outcome.
The appeal is limited to the trial court record, which includes the transcript of the proceedings, exhibits, and written filings. It’s a written, procedural process—not a chance to tell your story again.
The person appealing is called the appellant; the opposing party is the appellee. The goal is to show that the trial court made a reversible error—whether in applying the law, ruling on evidence, or drawing conclusions not supported by the record.
To understand what happens during the process, visit: What Happens During an Indiana Family Law Appeal?
Why is it So Difficult to Win an Indiana Divorce Appeal?
Appealing a divorce or custody ruling is challenging for several reasons. First, trial judges in Indiana have broad discretion in family law matters. That means appellate courts are reluctant to second-guess decisions about custody, parenting time, property division, or spousal support—especially when the ruling is based on the judge’s direct observations of witnesses and evidence.
Second, the standard of review is limited. If the judge made a decision that was within the range of reasonableness, even if another judge might have ruled differently, the appellate court is likely to uphold it.
However, if the decision was based on a misapplication of the law, a procedural violation, or findings that are unsupported by the record, you may have grounds to appeal. That includes situations where the court abused its discretion or made clearly erroneous factual findings.
Top Grounds for Appealing a Divorce or Custody Ruling in Indiana
While difficult, an appeal can be successful when the trial court made specific types of legal or factual errors. Here are the most common grounds:
Legal Error
One of the strongest bases for an appeal is when the judge misapplies Indiana law or fails to follow required legal procedures.
Misapplication or Misinterpretation of Indiana Law
This may occur when the court:
Applies child support guidelines incorrectly.
Divides marital property without following Indiana’s equitable distribution statute.
Ignores required statutory factors in a custody decision.
If a judge gets the law wrong, and that mistake affects the outcome of the case, the appellate court can reverse the ruling or send the case back for correction.
Procedural Error or Due Process Violation
Sometimes the court’s handling of the trial itself is flawed. This includes:
Refusing to allow a party to present key evidence or witnesses.
Improperly admitting or excluding evidence.
Failing to make findings of fact when required.
Violating a party’s right to notice or a fair hearing.
Procedural errors can be especially damaging in custody cases, where missed evidence or skewed procedures may alter the outcome dramatically.
Abuse of Discretion
Judges have flexibility in making decisions—but that flexibility has limits. A ruling is an "abuse of discretion" when it is clearly unreasonable, arbitrary, or unsupported by the facts.
Examples include:
Awarding custody to a parent despite documented safety concerns and contrary expert testimony.
Dividing marital property unequally without any explanation or justification in the record.
Ordering extreme attorney fee awards not supported by either party’s financial documents.
In these situations, the appellate court reviews whether the trial judge’s decision falls outside the range of reasonableness given the evidence presented.
Clearly Erroneous Findings of Fact / Insufficient Evidence
Factual findings can also be challenged on appeal—especially when they are completely unsupported by the trial record.
Examples include:
A court finds that a parent is stable and appropriate for custody when the evidence at trial overwhelmingly shows the opposite.
The judge adopts a property valuation without any expert opinion, documentation, or testimony to support it.
If the trial court’s findings are clearly erroneous or not supported by any probative evidence, the appellate court may reverse or remand.
Newly Discovered Evidence (Rare)
Occasionally, new evidence surfaces after the trial that could not have been discovered earlier with reasonable diligence—and that evidence might have changed the outcome.
Examples:
Discovering hidden bank accounts or assets that were intentionally concealed during discovery.
Finding evidence that a key witness lied under oath about a central issue, and that lie wasn’t detectable during trial.
Newly discovered evidence is rarely a winning ground for appeal, but it can support a motion to reopen the case or pursue relief under Trial Rule 60.
Fraud or Judicial Misconduct
In extreme cases, you may be able to appeal based on misconduct by the opposing party—or even by the judge.
Examples:
A spouse deliberately conceals major financial assets and lies under oath about them.
The judge demonstrates clear bias, hostility, or personal involvement that compromises fairness.
Navigating the complexities of an Indiana family law appeal requires precise legal knowledge and experience. If you believe your divorce or custody ruling contains an error that warrants an appeal, don’t wait.
Contact Vining Legal today to discuss your options. Schedule your free consultation by calling or texting (317) 759-3225 or visiting our contact page.
What Cannot Be Appealed (and What Might Be a Post-Divorce Modification)
Appeals must be based on legal or procedural errors—not simply dissatisfaction with the outcome. Here are situations that usually cannot support an appeal:
You disagree with the outcome: If there was evidence supporting both sides and the judge picked one, that’s not appealable.
You didn’t present certain evidence: If you had access to important information but chose not to present it, the appellate court won’t consider it now.
You’re unhappy with your attorney: Poor strategy or communication by your lawyer may be frustrating, but it’s not grounds to reverse a court’s decision.
What to Do Instead: Consider a Post-Divorce Modification
If your circumstances have changed since the original ruling, you might be eligible to modify custody, parenting time, or support. This includes situations like:
A parent moving out of state.
A child developing new medical or educational needs.
A significant change in income or employment.
These changes don’t justify an appeal, but they can support a petition to modify the court’s existing order.
To learn more, visit: When can you Modify a Custody Order
The Importance of Experienced Appellate Counsel
Appeals are not just continuations of trial work. They involve:
Strict deadlines (often 30 days to file a notice of appeal).
Detailed procedural and formatting rules.
Legal writing and persuasive analysis tailored to appellate judges.
A successful appeal requires reviewing the trial record for appealable issues, framing legal arguments under the correct standard of review, and crafting a compelling brief.
At Vining Legal, we understand the appellate process and how to spot legal or factual errors that justify reversal. We’ve helped clients win appeals in complex divorce and custody matters where trial courts made clear mistakes.
Case Example
In one recent case, we helped a client overturn a trial court’s property division after proving the judge miscalculated a key marital asset. The appellate court agreed, resulting in a more equitable financial outcome.
Conclusion
Appealing a divorce or custody ruling in Indiana is not easy—but it may be the right move when the trial court has made a serious legal or factual error. Appeals are not about re-arguing your case; they’re about correcting clear mistakes that led to an unjust outcome.
If you believe your ruling was wrong, don’t let the deadline pass without a legal review.
Call Vining Legal at (317) 759-3225 or visit our contact page to schedule your free consultation. Let us help you determine whether appealing a divorce or custody ruling in Indiana is the right path for you.
Schedule a Consultation
-
You can, but simply being unhappy with the outcome isn’t enough to support a sucessful appeal. To file a successful appeal in Indiana, you must show that the trial court made a legal error, abused its discretion, or based its decision on findings that were clearly unsupported by the evidence. If the judge acted within the bounds of the law and there was evidence supporting their ruling, the appellate court will usually affirm the decision.
-
You can appeal a divorce or custody ruling in Indiana if you can demonstrate:
Legal error: The judge misapplied or misinterpreted Indiana law.
Procedural error: The court failed to follow required procedures or denied you a fair hearing.
Abuse of discretion: The decision was unreasonable or unsupported by the evidence.
Clearly erroneous findings of fact: The judge made factual findings that had no support in the trial record.
Newly discovered evidence: New evidence surfaced after trial that couldn’t have been found earlier and would likely change the result.
Fraud or judicial misconduct: One party committed fraud, or the judge demonstrated bias.
-
In most cases, you have 30 days from the date of the final order to file a Notice of Appeal in Indiana. This is a strict deadline. Missing it could result in losing your right to appeal, no matter how strong your case may be. If you're considering an appeal, speak with an appellate attorney immediately to preserve your rights.
