What Is One Reason Prosecutors May Decide to Dismiss Cases?

Criminal Defense
Written By Nathan Vining

Understanding Why Criminal Charges Get Dropped

If you’ve been charged with a crime in Indiana, you may be wondering: Can my case be dismissed? Prosecutors have the power to drop or dismiss charges, but they don’t do so without a valid legal reason.

At Vining Legal, we help clients identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case and fight for dismissals whenever possible. Here’s one of the most common reasons prosecutors choose to dismiss cases.

The #1 Reason Prosecutors Dismiss Criminal Cases

One of the most common reasons a prosecutor may dismiss a case is lack of sufficient evidence.

Why Does Lack of Evidence Lead to Dismissal?

For a conviction, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you committed the crime. If there isn’t enough solid evidence, the prosecutor may:
✔ Decide the case isn't strong enough to win in court.
✔ Drop the charges before trial to avoid losing.
✔ Dismiss the case due to unreliable or missing evidence.

What Types of Evidence Can Be Weak or Missing?

1. Insufficient Physical Evidence

  • No forensic evidence (DNA, fingerprints, or weapons) linking you to the crime.

  • Lack of surveillance footage or phone records.

2. Unreliable Witness Testimony

  • Witnesses change their stories or refuse to testify.

  • Key witnesses have criminal records or personal biases.

3. Violation of Your Constitutional Rights

  • If evidence was illegally obtained, your defense attorney can file a motion to suppress it.

  • If crucial evidence is thrown out, the prosecutor may be forced to dismiss the case.

🔗 Related Read: Understanding Evidence Suppression in Indiana Criminal Cases

Other Reasons Prosecutors May Dismiss Cases

While lack of evidence is a major reason, prosecutors may also dismiss cases due to:

✔ Illegal Search & Seizure – If police violated your Fourth Amendment rights, key evidence may be inadmissible.
✔ Uncooperative Witnesses – If key witnesses refuse to testify, the case may fall apart.
✔ Prosecutorial Discretion – Sometimes, prosecutors prioritize more serious cases and decide not to pursue minor offenses.
✔ Diversion Programs – Some first-time offenders qualify for pretrial diversion programs, leading to dismissal after completion.

How Can You Get Your Case Dismissed?

To increase your chances of dismissal, a skilled defense attorney can:
✅ Challenge weak evidence and file motions to suppress.
✅ Expose constitutional violations that could invalidate the case.
✅ Negotiate with prosecutors for a dismissal or reduction in charges.

Vining Legal Fights for Case Dismissals

At Vining Legal, we:
✔ Examine every detail of your case for legal weaknesses.
✔ File suppression motions to remove bad evidence.
✔ Negotiate aggressively with prosecutors.

📞 Call or text (317) 759-3225 for a free consultation today.
🔗 Visit Vining Legal to schedule a consultation to get started with your defense.

Featured
First-Time Cocaine Possession in Indiana: What to Expect and How to Move Forward
Drug Offense, Cocaine
First-Time Cocaine Possession in Indiana: What to Expect and How to Move Forward
Drug Offense, Cocaine

Facing a cocaine possession charge in Indiana for the first time can feel like your world is collapsing. You might be wondering: What happens next? Will this ruin my future? At Vining Legal, we’ve seen the fear and uncertainty that come with a first-time cocaine possession Indiana charge. Indiana law treats cocaine possession seriously, even for first-time offenders, but you’re not without options. This guide walks you through what to expect after your arrest, the potential penalties, and how an experienced criminal defense attorney can help you protect your rights and move toward a better outcome. A single mistake doesn’t have to define your life—keep reading to understand your next steps.

Read More →
Drug Offense, Cocaine
What to Do Right Away If a Protective Order Is Filed Against You
Domestic Battery, Protective Order
What to Do Right Away If a Protective Order Is Filed Against You
Domestic Battery, Protective Order

The issuance of a protective order against you can be a profoundly disruptive event, imposing immediate legal restrictions and obligations under Indiana law. With a court hearing on the horizon and potential consequences looming, swift and informed action is essential. Our Indiana law firm has extensive experience assisting clients in these challenging circumstances, and we are prepared to guide you. Below, we outline the critical steps to take immediately if a protective order is filed against you to safeguard your rights and position yourself effectively.

Read More →
Domestic Battery, Protective Order
The Science Behind BAC Testing: How It Works and Where It Can Go Wrong
OWI
The Science Behind BAC Testing: How It Works and Where It Can Go Wrong
OWI

Imagine this: You’re driving home after a dinner where you had a single glass of wine. A police officer pulls you over, suspects you’ve been drinking, and asks you to blow into a breathalyzer. Minutes later, you’re facing a DUI charge based on a Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) reading. That little number—say, 0.08%—could change your life. But how reliable is it? BAC testing is a cornerstone of DUI enforcement in Indiana and beyond, rooted in science yet far from perfect. Understanding how BAC tests work and where they can fail might just be your key to fighting back.

Read More →
OWI
3 Reasons a Protective Order Might Get Dismissed in Indiana
Domestic Battery, Protective Order
3 Reasons a Protective Order Might Get Dismissed in Indiana
Domestic Battery, Protective Order

Protective orders are serious legal tools in Indiana, often issued to shield someone from harm in domestic violence cases. But what happens when you’re falsely accused of domestic violence and slapped with a protective order (PO) you don’t deserve? It’s a stressful, life-altering situation. The good news? Not every protective order sticks. In fact, there are several reasons a protective order might get dismissed in Indiana, giving the falsely accused a chance to fight back and clear their name.

Read More →
Domestic Battery, Protective Order
Nathan Vining
Previous

What Is the Burden of Proof in a Criminal Case?
Next

What Are the Signs of a Weak Criminal Case?