5 Costly Mistakes to Avoid During Indiana Probate

I. Introduction

Losing a loved one is emotionally difficult—and navigating the legal process that follows can be just as overwhelming. Probate, the court-supervised process of distributing a deceased person’s estate, often adds legal, financial, and emotional stress to an already challenging time.

In Indiana, probate ensures that debts are paid, assets are properly distributed, and the decedent’s wishes—if a will exists—are honored. While the process is meant to provide structure, it can quickly become complicated and drawn-out if mistakes are made along the way.

This post highlights five common and costly mistakes families make during Indiana probate—and how to avoid them. By staying informed and proactive, you can help streamline the process, reduce conflict, and protect the estate.

II. Mistake 1: Failing to File the Will Promptly

Indiana's Filing Requirements

Under Indiana law, a will must be filed with the probate court within a reasonable time after the death—typically 30 days. Failing to file promptly can result in unnecessary legal complications.

Consequences of Delay

• Disputes among beneficiaries

• Claims that the will was intentionally concealed

• Delays in accessing estate assets

• Increased court costs and administrative fees

The Process

To file the will, the executor or next of kin should submit the original document to the probate court in the county where the decedent resided. The court will then determine whether to open a formal or informal probate proceeding.

Acting quickly after a death not only ensures compliance but can help preserve peace among grieving family members.

III. Mistake 2: Improperly Valuing Assets

Why It Matters

Accurately valuing the decedent’s assets is crucial for:

• Determining tax obligations

• Distributing assets fairly

• Satisfying creditor claims

• Avoiding disputes

Common Valuation Mistakes

• Underestimating the value of real estate

• Failing to include personal property (vehicles, collections, jewelry)

• Overlooking digital assets like cryptocurrency, online businesses, or monetized social media

• Using outdated or biased estimates

Best Practices

• Hire qualified appraisers for real estate and high-value items

• Keep detailed inventories

• Understand the difference between fair market value and replacement cost—only the former is typically relevant to probate

An inaccurate valuation can trigger tax issues, inheritance disputes, and challenges from beneficiaries.

IV. Mistake 3: Neglecting Creditor Claims

Indiana's Creditor Notification Rules

In Indiana, the personal representative (executor) must notify known creditors and publish a notice to unknown creditors. Creditors then have three months from the date of notice to file a claim against the estate.

What Happens If You Ignore Creditors?

• The estate may be held liable for unpaid debts

• Personal liability may arise for the executor

• Asset distributions may need to be reversed

How to Handle It

• Publish notice in a local newspaper as required by Indiana law

• Send direct notice to known creditors

• Maintain organized records of all claims, payments, and disputes

Addressing claims properly ensures the estate is distributed legally—and avoids trouble later.

V. Mistake 4: Mishandling Estate Taxes

Understanding Tax Obligations

• Indiana does not have an inheritance tax (repealed in 2013), but certain beneficiaries in other states may still be affected.

• The federal estate tax only applies to estates over $13.61 million (as of 2024), but tax obligations still exist:

  • Final income tax return

  • Estate income tax (Form 1041, if the estate earns income)

  • Property tax or capital gains

Common Tax Mistakes

• Missing deadlines for tax returns

• Failing to report all assets or income

• Misunderstanding applicable exemptions

• Not consulting with a tax professional

Deadlines and Penalties

Late filings can result in interest, penalties, and even personal liability for the executor. Consulting a tax advisor early in the process is critical.

VI. Mistake 5: Poor Communication and Record-Keeping

Communication Is Key

Beneficiaries and creditors want transparency. Failure to keep them informed can lead to:

• Suspicion and conflict

• Formal objections in court

• Delays in closing the estate

The Role of Good Record-Keeping

Executors are expected to document all financial activity, including:

• Receipts

• Disbursements

• Asset sales

• Payments to creditors

• Communications with beneficiaries

Best Practices

• Use estate accounting software or spreadsheets

• Keep copies of all correspondence and financial documents

• Provide regular updates to beneficiaries

Clear records not only protect the executor—they also help build trust among everyone involved.

VII. The Importance of Professional Legal Counsel

Probate Is Complex—Don’t Go It Alone

Indiana probate law can be nuanced and time-sensitive. An experienced probate attorney can:

• Ensure compliance with court procedures

• Avoid costly mistakes

• Resolve disputes before they escalate

• Manage tax and creditor issues

• Guide executors from start to finish

Risks of DIY Probate

Even simple estates can involve hidden complexities. Attempting to manage probate without legal help can lead to delays, disputes, and increased liability for the executor.

VIII. Conclusion

Recap: 5 Costly Mistakes to Avoid

1. Failing to file the will promptly

2. Improperly valuing assets

3. Neglecting creditor claims

4. Mishandling estate taxes

5. Poor communication and record-keeping

Each of these mistakes can significantly complicate the probate process—but they’re avoidable with the right preparation and support.

If you're managing an estate in Indiana, don't take chances. At Vining Legal, we help families and executors navigate probate smoothly and confidently.

Call or text (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation to get the legal guidance you need today.

Schedule a Consultation