How to Appeal a DCS Substantiation in Indiana: Understanding the Two-Step Process
Introduction: Taking Action After a DCS Substantiation
If you have received a Notice of Right to Appeal a Child Abuse or Neglect Substantiation from the Indiana Department of Child Services (DCS), it means the agency has determined there is enough evidence to substantiate an allegation against you. A substantiation can have serious consequences, including being listed on Indiana’s Child Protection Index (CPI), which can affect your ability to work in certain fields and impact custody rights.
However, you have the right to challenge this decision. The appeal process involves two steps:
Requesting an Administrative Review (Step 1)
Requesting an Administrative Appeal Hearing (Step 2)
It is important to act quickly, as both steps have strict deadlines. Missing a deadline could result in the substantiation remaining on your record permanently.
Step 1: Requesting an Administrative Review of a DCS Substantiation
What Is an Administrative Review?
An Administrative Review is the first step in the appeal process. It allows a DCS representative who was not involved in the original investigation to review the findings and determine whether the substantiation should be reversed.
How to Request an Administrative Review
To request a review, you must:
✔ Fill out the Request for Administrative Review of Child Abuse or Neglect Substantiation (State Form 54775)
✔ Attach a copy of the assessment summary (State Form 113 / CW 311)
✔ Submit both forms to the place listed on the notice
Deadlines for Filing a Request
✔ You have 15 days from the date on the notification letter to submit your request.
✔ If the notification letter was mailed, you get an additional three days for mailing time.
What Happens Next?
Once you submit your request:
✔ A different DCS official reviews the findings.
✔ They may contact you for additional information or documentation.
✔ You will receive a written decision on whether the substantiation is upheld or reversed.
If DCS reverses the substantiation, your case is closed, and your record will not reflect the finding.
If the substantiation is upheld, you will receive a Notice of Right to Administrative Appeal, allowing you to proceed to Step 2.
Step 2: Requesting an Administrative Appeal Hearing
What Is an Administrative Appeal Hearing?
If the Administrative Review does not overturn the substantiation, you have the right to request a formal hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). This is your opportunity to present evidence, call witnesses, and challenge the substantiation in a formal legal setting.
How to Request an Administrative Appeal Hearing
To request a hearing, you must:
✔ Submit the Request for Administrative Appeal Hearing for Child Abuse or Neglect Substantiation (State Form 54776)
✔ Attach a copy of the Notice of Right to Appeal (State Form 55148)
✔ Include a copy of the approved assessment (State Form 113 / CW 311)
✔ Send all required documents to the DCS Hearings and Appeals Division
Deadlines for Filing a Request
✔ You have 30 days from the date on the Notice of Right to Appeal to submit your request.
✔ If the notice was mailed, you get an additional three days for mailing time.
What Happens at the Hearing?
✔ The Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) will review all evidence.
✔ You can present documents, witness testimony, and legal arguments.
✔ DCS will have a representative arguing why the substantiation should remain.
✔ The ALJ will issue a decision, which may reverse or uphold the substantiation.
Why Legal Representation Is Important
While you are allowed to represent yourself during both the Administrative Review and Appeal Hearing, the process can be legally complex. Having an attorney can help by:
✔ Ensuring all required forms and deadlines are met.
✔ Identifying weaknesses in the DCS case and gathering evidence to challenge it.
✔ Presenting legal arguments before the Administrative Law Judge.
✔ Cross-examining DCS witnesses and challenging procedural errors.
An experienced attorney can increase your chances of successfully overturning a substantiation, which can help protect your reputation, career, and parental rights.
Conclusion: Act Quickly to Protect Your Rights
If you have received a Notice of Right to Appeal a Child Abuse/Neglect Substantiation, do not ignore it. The appeal process is time-sensitive, and failing to act within the deadlines can leave the substantiation on your record permanently.
✔ Step 1: File a Request for Administrative Review (Form 54775) within 15 days.
✔ Step 2: If denied, submit a Request for an Administrative Appeal Hearing (Form 54776) within 30 days.
📞 Need help fighting a DCS substantiation? Contact Vining Legal LLC at (317) 759-3225 or schedule a consultation today.
Schedule a Consultation
